A Cronkite News Service Weekend Special
Voters deciding the future of dozens of rural Arizona school districts
NOTE: This story moved Wednesday, Oct. 1. We recommend it for weekend use.
With BC-CNS-Rural Redistricting-Box
Download Photo (thumbnail, caption below)
By GREG LINDSAY
Cronkite News Service
STANFIELD _ Olivia Rodriguez graduated from Stanfield Elementary School in this farming and ranching community. Her four sons graduated from the school. Now three of her grandchildren go there.
It’s the only school in the Stanfield Elementary School District, though the district is expected to grow in coming years along with the rest of Pinal County. Like Rodriguez did, the school’s 786 students move on to the Casa Grande Union High School District.
The arrangement works for Stanfield, said Rodriguez, president and longtime member of the school board.
“Our kids are doing just fine,” Rodriguez said.
But things could change in November, when voters decide whether to endorse a proposal to combine the Stanfield Elementary School District with a piece of the Casa Grande Union High School District. It’s part of a larger plan that would create seven unified districts out of seven elementary school districts and two high school districts across Pinal County.
The 13-member School District Redistricting Commission, created by the Arizona State Legislature, presented Gov. Janet Napolitano with a plan that will have voters in 76 school districts around Arizona deciding whether to create unified districts. If all of the plans are approved, there would be 27 unified districts instead.
Forty-two of the districts where voters are deciding are outside of Maricopa County and in rural areas. Besides Pinal and Maricopa, counties where voters are considering changes are Cochise, La Paz, Mohave, Pima, Santa Cruz, Yavapai and Yuma.
Gary Emanuel, an associate professor in educational leadership at Northern Arizona University, said many of the elementary districts considering unification were formed at the turn of the century, when less than 5 percent of the population attended school beyond the sixth or eighth grade.
“Elementary districts were formed first; some of the later districts formed unified districts,” he said. “High schools were a late-19th century idea.”
Proponents of the unification plans say combining districts can put more money toward instruction by reducing administrative costs, but opponents say it isn’t clear how the plans would affect the finances of districts.
Rodriguez said a key issue in Stanfield is who best can serve the needs of students. She said most residents agree that the district as it’s currently structured is doing that well.
“The needs of kids in rural districts are different than they would be in bigger districts,” Rodriguez said.
Like most districts facing unification votes, the Stanfield Elementary School District and the Casa Grande Union High School District are urging voters to defeat the plan.
Nancy Pifer, superintendent of the Casa Grande Union High School District, which would join with three elementary districts, said combining districts would require money the state hasn’t provided. Her concerns include how to deal with differing pay scales and tax rates in different districts.
She said her district already provides a seamless transition to high school for students from the various districts.
“Don’t get me wrong; we’re not perfect,” Pifer said. “But we’re working on that, and we don’t need unification to do it.”
Jay Blanchard, a member of the School District Redistricting Commission and an Arizona State University professor of psychology in education, said the biggest issue facing districts is fear of the unknown.
“These school districts have been around for 100-plus years, and most generations have an allegiance to their school district, an allegiance to their sports teams, an allegiance to their schools,” Blanchard said. “And sometimes change can be scary.”
But Chris Thomas, general counsel for the Arizona School Boards Association, said voters should be concerned about how much unification could cost because the state hasn’t committed money to help districts make it happen. Thomas said merging salary schedules and dealing with contracts for duplicate services are two examples.
“My real problem is the uncertainty that will happen with the plan,” said Thomas, who also serves as president of Madison Elementary School District, a Phoenix-area district considering unification. “Instead of a financial saving, there will be a financial burden.”
The Arizona School Boards Association opposes unification plans for which all school boards are against the change.
Martin Shultz, chairman of the School District Redistricting Commission, said school districts are trying to throw people off by contending that the unification plan is incomplete.
“The resistance to change, you can cut it with a knife. It’s very thick,” Shultz said.
“While I know it’s meaningful to them, we’re trying to improve education for Arizona students,” Shultz said. “This is very important to the future of education.”
But for residents of Stanfield, Olivia Rodriguez said, the issue comes down to how to serve the community’s children.
“We’re not afraid of change,” she said. “We want the best for our kids.”
^___=
Web Link:
_ School District Redistricting Commission: www.ade.state.az.us/sdrc
^___=
PHOTO:
Click thumbnails to see full-resolution images and download; caption information is in the file under File>File Info.
CAPTION FOR BC-CNS-RURAL REDISTRICTING: Olivia Rodriguez, longtime school board member in the Stanfield Elementary School District in Pinal County, is joined by her grandchildren outside Stanfield Elementary School, the district’s only school. From left to right: Austin Rodriguez, 8; Olivia Rodriguez holding Samantha Rodriguez, 3; and Michael Rodriguez, 13. Olivia Rodriguez says a plan to unite her district with a portion of the Casa Grande Union High School District isn’t in the best interest of students because the district as structured knows how to meet the community’s needs. Of the 76 districts around Arizona deciding whether to combine into unified districts, 42 are in rural areas outside Maricopa County. (Cronkite News Service Photo/Greg Lindsay)